Nostalgia

Nostalgic and old-fashioned candy selections include “penny” candies, old school soda pop, hard-to-find vintage candy brands and cool retro products like Pop Rocks, Astro Pops, and Clark Bars. These time-tested favorites have delighted customers for generations.

Alphabetically, A-Z
3 Color Neapolitan Coconut Bar 1.65 Oz
$25.92
Box N Case 3 Color Neapolitan Coconut Bar 1.65 Oz
$25.92
6 Pack Empty Carriers
$31.95
Orca 6 Pack Empty Carriers
$31.95
Abba Zaba Mystery Flavor Taffy 1.25 Oz - 288ct Case
$599.76
Annabelle Abba Zaba Mystery Flavor Taffy 1.25 Oz - 288ct Case
$599.76
Americana Root Beer 12 Oz Bottle
$50.04
Americana Soda Americana Root Beer 12 Oz Bottle
$50.04
Americana Black Cherry Soda 12 Oz Bottle
$50.04
Orca Americana Black Cherry Soda 12 Oz Bottle
$50.04
Americana Cherry Cola 12 Oz Bottle
$50.04
Americana Soda Americana Cherry Cola 12 Oz Bottle
$50.04
Americana Honey Lime Ginger Soda 12 Oz Bottle
$53.64
Americana Soda Americana Honey Lime Ginger Soda 12 Oz Bottle
$53.64
Americana Honeycream Soda 12 Oz Bottle
$50.04
Americana Soda Americana Honeycream Soda 12 Oz Bottle
$50.04
Americana Hucklebery Soda 12 Oz Bottle
$50.04
Americana Soda Americana Hucklebery Soda 12 Oz Bottle
$50.04
Americana Orange Cream Soda 12 Oz Bottle
$50.04
Americana Soda Americana Orange Cream Soda 12 Oz Bottle
$50.04
Soldout
Anchor Soda Ginger Root Beer 4 Pack 12 Oz Bottle
$48.60
Anchor Anchor Soda Ginger Root Beer 4 Pack 12 Oz Bottle
$48.60
Annabelle's Abba-Zaba 2 Oz Bar
$35.28
Annabelle Annabelle's Abba-Zaba 2 Oz Bar
$35.28
Annabelle's Big Hunk 2 Oz Bar
$35.28
Annabelle Annabelle's Big Hunk 2 Oz Bar
$35.28
Annabelle's Look Bar 1.5 Oz
$35.28
ANNABELLE Annabelle's Look Bar 1.5 Oz
$35.28
Annabelle's Look Bar 1.5 Oz
$35.28
Annabelle Annabelle's Look Bar 1.5 Oz
$35.28
Annabelle's Rocky Road 1.82 Oz Bar
$35.28
Annabelle Annabelle's Rocky Road 1.82 Oz Bar
$35.28
Annabelle's U-No 1.5 Oz Bar
$35.28
Annabelle Annabelle's U-No 1.5 Oz Bar
$35.28
Astro Pop 1.5 Oz
$77.40
Leaf Brands Astro Pop 1.5 Oz
$77.40
Atkinson Peanut Butter Bars
$49.73
Atkinson Atkinson Peanut Butter Bars
$49.73
Atkinson Sugar Free Chick O Stick Bites
$228.15
Chick-O-Stick Atkinson Sugar Free Chick O Stick Bites
$228.15
Atkinson Sugar Free Peanut Butter Bars
$202.73
Atkinson Atkinson Sugar Free Peanut Butter Bars
$202.73
Atkinson Wrapped Chick O Stick Bites
$50.55
Chick-O-Stick Atkinson Wrapped Chick O Stick Bites
$50.55
Atomic Fireballs Wrapped
$41.85
Atomic Fireball Atomic Fireballs Wrapped
$41.85
Australian Style Hot Ginger Ale 12 Oz Bottle
$66.60
Australian Australian Style Hot Ginger Ale 12 Oz Bottle
$66.60
Filter:
659 products
Brand
Brand
0 selected Reset
Availability
Availability
0 selected Reset
Price
Price
The highest price is $859.68 Reset
$
-
$
Size
Size
0 selected Reset